Perhaps you have read or heard that milk contains pus. Articles like this one from nutritionfacts.org have certainly played their part in spreading this myth, claiming that mastitis runs rampant in the dairy industry and that the milk from these cows is saturated with pus (along with the highly inaccurate claim that most cows are only productive for two years). http://nutritionfacts.org/2011/09/08/how-much-pus-is-there-in-milk/ Perhaps you’ve seen inflammatory infographics like this one:
A dairy friend of mine says that the NotMilk website is aptly named: it is most certainly not milk what is described there! And that bit about casein: human breast milk also contains casein. It’s not likely to be deadly, is it?!Maybe you’ve even had the dubious pleasure of watching the same video I have, where the somber voice over gleefully chortles about the millions of pus cells present in each glass of milk.
So…Is there pus in milk??? Absolutely not. As a dairy farmer, I work with our cows and their milk daily, and I know that this is not true. Allow me to explain…
Where do these rumours begin? Like all mammals, cows produce milk after giving birth. Sometimes a cow will develop an infection of the udder called mastitis. For those familiar with breastfeeding, you’ll know that humans too can develop mastitis. This accurate definition from Wikipedia sums up mastitis clearly and succinctly: “Mastitis occurs when white blood cells are released into the mammary gland, usually in response to an invasion of bacteria of the teat canal. Milk-secreting tissue and various ducts throughout the mammary gland are damaged due to toxins by the bacteria. Mastitis can also occur as a result of chemical, mechanical, or thermal injury. The udder sac is hard, tight, and firm. This disease can be identified by abnormalities in the udder such as swelling, heat, redness, hardness or pain if it is clinical. Other indications of mastitis may be abnormalities in milk such as a watery appearance, flakes, or clots.” Reading this definition, one can almost understand why a person not familiar with procedures and practices on a dairy farm could be led to believe that there is pus in milk, especially after reading false statistics claiming widespread incidences of mastitis in dairy cows. Yes, cows can get mastitis. It can be a debilitating, even life threatening infection if not treated properly and promptly. As farmers, we take each case of mastitis very seriously. When mastitis is detected, either via testing or the daily visual inspection of each cow’s milk before the milking machine is attached, the milk from that cow does not enter the supply chain until the infection has cleared. Depending on the severity of the infection, there are a few different ways to treat mastitis. If the infection is not too virulent, hot compresses and massages and stripping out the milk from the infected part of the udder can sometimes help the cow get rid of the infection on her own. Other times, antibiotic treatment is necessary. When a cow is treated with antibiotics, her milk also does not enter the supply chain and is discarded until the drug specific withdrawal time has passed. Additionally, all milk is tested on farm and at the processing plant for antibiotic residues; if residues are detected, all contaminated milk is discarded and the farmer responsible pays a hefty fine. Once a cow has recovered and her milk has tested clear of antibiotic residues, her milk is once again shipped to the processing plant.
A healthy udder on a healthy cow before and after milking. No swelling, hard quarters or redness to indicate mastitis. A few squirts of milk were expressed before milking to check for irregularities in the milk. After milking, an antibacterial dip is applied to the teats to prevent bacteria from entering the open teat end.Is mastitis rampant in the dairy industry? No! Take this blurb from the Code of Practice for the Care and Handling of Dairy Cattle: “Overall goals to strive for are: b) Reduction in the occurrence of clinical mastitis to two or fewer clinical cases per 100 cows per month.” Adherence to the Code is now mandatory on all dairy farms across Canada. These guidelines were written to be realistic and practical for dairy farms. If mastitis were rampant, aiming for an incidence level of less than 2% per month wouldn’t be feasible. We aim to reduce cases of mastitis by ensuring that our cows live in a clean and sanitary environment. We keep their stalls full of fresh, clean bedding; we clean the barns of manure multiple times per day; we utilize sanitary practices during the milking of each cow; we ensure that our milking equipment is properly maintained and serviced, and we apply an antibacterial teat protecting dip after milking when the open teat end could allow the entry of bacteria.
Now, let’s take a look at these “pus cells” that anti-dairy groups claim are in the milk you drink.
To tell you the truth, there is no such thing as a “pus cell”. Pus is made up of dead white blood cells, dead skin cells, and bacteria, not one type of cell.
So to what are these people referring? Generally, these “experts” equate somatic cells with pus cells. Somatic cells are living white blood cells located in the udder of cows. Like all white blood cells, they fight infection so an elevated somatic cell count indicates that the cow is fighting some sort of infection, such as mastitis. Milk is tested both on farm and at the processing plant, and one of the tests run is called a “somatic cell count” test. This test shows the level of somatic cells in a sample of milk. A healthy cow with no underlying infection will have a low somatic cell count (SCC). A cow with a somatic cell count below 100 000 cells per milliliter is considered to be in optimum health by most industry sources, she is not fighting any sort of mammary infection. Ontario’s Ministry of Agriculture, Food, and Rural Affairs states that “bulk tank counts or herd averages of under 200 000 indicate excellent udder health and counts over 500 000 indicate a definite problem with subclinical mastitis.” Most dairies aim to keep their SCC level under 200 000. An average monthly herd somatic cell count under 250 000 somatic cells per mL is also eligible for a quality bonus paid to the farmer. Typically about 80% of farms in our province receive a quality bonus each month. In Canada, the maximum allowable limit for somatic cells in milk is 400 000. This line is drawn to ensure that sick cows are treated and that their milk does not enter the food chain. Consumers can rest assured that their milk does not contain pus AND that it comes from healthy cows! (Just as an aside: the somatic cell count averages for our herd over our last three SCC tests were: 142 000 (Jan 5), 147 000 (Jan 12), 163 000 (Jan 19) ).
If you are looking for answers about dairy, please be critical. Why is the source presenting this information? Is there an underlying agenda? Try to find the source of the information, and verify that it is from an unbiased agency. Pages that push vegetarian or vegan diets or lifestyles may not be interested in telling the whole truth about dairy. While some may say that this article also is a biased source of information, remember that what I have described here is supported by the scientific and veterinarian communities. You’re welcome to double check my facts!
I hope that I’ve explained this issue clearly and logically. As always, questions or comments are more than welcome in the comments section below!
I hope the American dairy famers have the same law. I don-t want to drink pus in milk.
LikeLike
don’t
LikeLike
i don’t care .. not your milk !! why not suck them directly from the source !? And what u do with the calves, especially the male ones ? it is just a baby and u take it from his/her mother .. and after some month make it in veal ?! can u imagine a woman all her life to live in a room and to be forcibly impregnated every year so you can take her baby and suck her milk ?!
LikeLike
As excuse me. I wasn’t even talking to you in the first place And if you don’t even care, then why did you reply to my comment? Also sucking from a cow’s tits doesn’t seem very safe or clean. Also I don’t have or own a dairy farm ( did I ever mention? Nope). Next time don’t ass-ume. It makes you look stupid. 😀
LikeLike
Sorry. Nevermind. I thought you was relpying to be since that your comment was on my gmail, so that’s why I thought it was a relpy towards me.😅
LikeLike
Somatic cells = puss but the worst part about dairy is the casein which is a known carcinogen. Drink milk at your own peril.
LikeLike
That wasn’t for me, right?
LikeLike
Veal taste awesome..get over it and have a fat steak and a glass of milk
LikeLike
Actually I paid £1.25 in tesco so actually….. ITS MY MILK BI**H
LikeLike
Horrible industry … so babies are taken away from mom.. mom gets an infection… milk meant for baby is dumped down the drain… WTF is wrong with our species..
LikeLike
People are so stupid. Im very glad this, article cleared things up. This article has nothing to do with veal, but the moron above didnt get their nasty milk fantasy validated so they are bringing up veal? Stupid! Stick to the point, we are discussing milk…. and I appreciate this article and the facts presented.
LikeLike
Thank you for explaining the ‘milk puss myth.’
Can you reference a similar article about the ‘cheese is milk pus’ statements I hear almost every day?
LikeLike
Well, cheese comes from milk. So if there is no pus (one letter ‘s’) in milk then there is no pus in cheese either. As a general rule, it would be easier to link people to registered dietitians as they have PhD’s and know what they are talking about. Plus, if someone is trying to convince you to be scared of any particular food, whether it’s milk, sugar, aspartame, etc. it’s a good chance they have fallen for a conspiracy theory (that is making a lot of money).
LikeLike
So there is small amount of pus in our milk, but will there be less in the red low fat milk.. 👍
LikeLike
You clearly didn’t read the debunked myth!
There’s no pus in milk dumb ass
LikeLike
You say, pay attention to the sources of the articles you read as they may be biased and what do they have to gain? I would counter with what do plant based people have to gain? What do vegans have to gain? There is no money in being vegan. There is however, money in dairy farming. Follow the money. And then decide who to trust. The goal of animal activists is to have animals be free as nature intended and not to be used by humans. The goal of animal agriculture is to make money from animal products and slaughtering animals. In this case, it is the dairy industry that has everything to gain by saying that there is nothing wrong with milk. When in fact there is everything wrong with it and the the entire system of dairy and animal exploitation that comes with it.
LikeLike
Of course there’s money to be gained in veganism: from the self-proclaimed “experts” who get to sell their books and profit off of people’s ignorance. Never mind the higher-priced vegan food products that are sold.
Also, simply making money off of something (people need to make a living after all) doesn’t change what the actual science has to say, or what reality is.
If “nature intended” animals to never be used by humans, why did nature “intend” that humans would exist that would use animals for food, drink, and clothing?
The goal of the agricultural industry is to sustain human life and livelihood.
LikeLike
If there’s no puss in milk then why is there an acceptable limit 😂
LikeLike
Obviously you have not read the article 🙄 Somatic cells ARE NOT pus. End of story.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Somatic cell count IS NOT pus. Those who have an ideological or commercial reason to want us to fear milk are trying to convince us that SCC and pus are interchangeable terms. You either didn’t read or comprehend the article, or you are being purposely obtuse.
LikeLike
“If there’s no puss in milk, then why is there an acceptable limit”
A nonsensical question, and I think you know it. Somatic cell count, a measurement of the amount of white blood cells, IS NOT a measurement of pus. The purposeful conflating the two is a transparent semantic distortion. Here is an example of the logic you are using.
“Football is an activity that carries a high risk of injury, including that 1 out of 100 participants will suffer a concussive injury. Football is an activity that uses a ball. Ping pong is an activity that uses a ball, therefore ping pong is football and is an activity that carries a high risk of injury including that 1 in 100 participants will suffer a concussive injury.”
Another example: Table salt consists of sodium and chlorine molecules. Swimming pools are filled with water treated with chlorine and therefore contains chlorine. Since salt contains chlorine and swimming pools contain chlorine, when you go swimming you are actually swimming in table salt.
Here is your argument: Pus is a liquid that forms in infected tissue. Pus contains dead white blood cells, dead skin or tissue cells, and bacteria in a solution. Since pus contains white blood cells, anything that contains white blood cells is pus.
NO, there would be white blood cells, a somatic cell count, in milk even if an animal were completely free of infection. Infection and pus need not be present for there to be white blood cells.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well said. Very good illustration.
LikeLike
Does this article apply only to organic muck ?
LikeLike
So 2/100 get mastitis every month meaning about a quarter of them yearly.. so the stats are right hahahha. I’ve never even met a human mother who has had mastitis. There are often 10s if thousands of cows in one holding pen how is that okay??? All of our pandemics have come from our mistreatment of animals. Milk is such a low grade food and you must understand you’re fucking up the planet no? Being in the industry that you’re in? What ulterior motive does an anti dairy blog or something has.. they just don’t want animals to be hurt, humans, or the planet. Oh dear, what horrible people. The world is going vegan and I’m watching it happen. Markets change. Evolve or die. UK taxpayers paid over £500000 to advertise the drinking of milk during lockdown. During a fucking pandemic caused by your horrible fucked up industry.. why are you drinking a baby cows milk? Ridiculous, disgusting and entirely selfish. There’s enough plant food on this planet to feed every human being yet do you care? No cuz u want a burger ): ): none of you care do you? Selfish. So selfish.
LikeLike
Does this article only apply to organic milk ?
LikeLike
Does this article apply to only organic milk ?
LikeLike
Milk is a product of lactation and is thus meant to keep newborns and babies alive. And only babies of the mother, not other species! It contains cow’shormones. Besides, it contains casein which is addictive and that is why people can’t stop eating dairy. Read about casomorphine.
LikeLike
I see you don’t monetize inuddernews.com, don’t waste your traffic, you
can earn additional bucks every month with new monetization method.
This is the best adsense alternative for any type of website (they approve all sites), for more info simply search in gooogle: murgrabia’s tools
LikeLike
What happens to the somatic cells once they have reached the end of their capacity to fight an infection in the mammary glands? These dead somatic cells are what makes up puss as you mentioned in your article. Interested to know.
Also, is bovine casein the same as human casein? Most dairy allergies (not intolerances) is associated with bovine dairy casein.
LikeLike
This is in America.
According to the USDA, 1 in 6 dairy cows in the United States suffers from clinical mastitis, which is responsible for 1 in 6 dairy cow deaths on U.S. dairy farms. This level of disease is reflected in the concentration of somatic cells in the American milk supply. Somatic cell counts greater than a million per teaspoon are abnormal and “almost always” caused by mastitis. When a cow is infected, greater than 90% of the somatic cells in her milk are neutrophils, the inflammatory immune cells that form pus. The average somatic cell count in U.S. milk per spoonful is 1,120,000.
So how much pus is there in a glass of milk? Not much. A million cells per spoonful sounds like a lot, but pus is really concentrated. According to my calculations* based on USDA data released last month, the average cup of milk in the United States would not be expected to contain more than a single drop of pus.
According to the new USDA data, the American milk supply averages 224,000 somatic cells/ml (based on bulk tank samples taken from whole herds). Subtracting the 200,000 that could be present in nonmastitic milk and subtracting the non-inflammatory fraction (10%) leaves us with 21,600 neutrophils per ml, and multiplying that by the volume of milk in a cup (237ml) comes out to be about 5 million neutrophils per cup. Then it depends on the cellular concentration of pus. Pus usually has more than 10,000 cells/microliter, but “In purulent fluids, leukocyte count is commonly much lower than expected because dead cells or other debris account for much of the turbidity,” and so apparent “pure pus” may have <10,000 cells/microliter. Conservatively using what was described in the medical literature as frank pus (80,000 cells/microliter) and converting from microliters to drop (50 microliter/drop) would mean 4 million cells per drop. Assuming the excess neutrophils drawn to the infected udder are pus-forming, 5 million divided by 4 million equals little more than a single pus-drop per cup (though I guess that could mean as much as 2 or 3 per tall frosty glass).
LikeLike
Not saying this is in your milk, but…
LikeLike
Hello. Some time ago I pretended to have read this post and made some kind of angry comment here. I was vegan. And I can tell you that vegans are very ignorant when it comes to information that doesn’t harmonize with their philosophy. I’m here now to apologise. I’m sure you don’t remember me, but I am sorry regardless. Dairy is one of the foods I swear I could feel immediately bringing me back to life after I abandoned veganism due to declining health. So, thank you for the work you do. Take care.
LikeLike
Wow! Thank you for this comment. And so so impressed that you came back to share your experience. Be well!
LikeLike